|

Do Dramaturgs Care About Criticism?

ON CRITICISM - by G.L. Horton

GO wrote: "But I applaud the erudition his reviews often display and which I see hardly anywhere (Chris Isherwood now at the Times a very welcome exception). Maybe dramaturgs just don't as a rule care about criticism?"

I care about criticism: Reading criticism in my local public library was the way I experienced in my mind's eye all the theatre I wanted to experience but couldn't see, growing up in the Midwest.

One of my pet peeves is that there are not enough women working as reviewers. I assume that the theatre audience, which is 67% female, would be better served if the Voice of Criticism wasn't so lopsidedly male. But I was shocked---shocked! at Anita Gates review in Tuesday's NY Times.

Here's the letter I wrote to the Editor of The New York Times:

Shouldn't Anita Gates' review of Michel Tremblay's "Les Belles Soeurs" mention that the play is French Canadian, written in a local patois and revolutionary at its 1966 premiere for its use of contemporary "street language"? The Canadian Theatre Encyclopedia describes Tremblay as "the most-produced playwright in the nation and arguably the most important playwright in the history of the country". If Gates is going to criticize the play's idioms, shouldn't she also mention the translation? Is it the standard English one, by Von Bureh and Glassco? Or one specific to this current "set in New England" production? Like many American theatre lovers outside New York, I depend on the NY Times to inform me about current productions in our cultural capital. Gate's comparison of Tremblay's play to a Waters film doesn't seem very helpful, either to people who have never heard of "Les Belles Soeurs" or to someone like me who has read it and seen productions. They need to know some basics-- such as that the "friends" Germaine invites over are literal not metaphorical sisters, a huge resentful brood born to a "belle" Catholic mother who believed that birth control is sinful. What I need to know is what the Women Speaking... theatre intended by this New England "take" on a Canadian classic, and whether their vision puts new life and relevance into an old play or removes the particulars that make it worth seeing. (5/13/05)

 

Archives—Essays and Commentary

Actors & Acting

On Criticism

Political Commentary

Literature

Plays: Shakespeare

Plays: Modern

Women's Issues

On Writing & Directing

Miscellaneous




 
home | bio | resume | blog | contact GL Horton
monologues | one-act plays | full-length plays
reviews | essays | links | videos
 

Made on an iMac by Websites 4 Small Business.